Here are the results from a South Atlantic MSE exercise testing the behavior of model-based versus empirical MPs for black sea bass (BSB), vermilion snapper (VS), and red porgy (RP) using the openMSE software (Blue Matter Science).
Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories
Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for model MPs
Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs
Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs
OM-specific MP biomass performance
OM-specific MP biomass performance
OM-specific MP biomass performance
OM-specific MP biomass performance
OM-specific MP biomass performance
OM-specific MP biomass performance
OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance
OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance
OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance
OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance
OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance
OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance
OM-specific MP yield performance
OM-specific MP yield performance
OM-specific MP yield performance
OM-specific MP yield performance
OM-specific MP yield performance
OM-specific MP yield performance
MP performance across OMs
MP performance across OMs
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
##
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202 11 192 77 147 169 78
MP performance across OMs
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
##
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202 11 192
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
##
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202 11 192
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
##
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202 11 192
MP performance across OMs
Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories
Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for model MPs
Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs
Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs
OM-specific MP biomass performance
OM-specific MP biomass performance
OM-specific MP biomass performance
OM-specific MP biomass performance
OM-specific MP biomass performance
OM-specific MP biomass performance
OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance
OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance
OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance
OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance
OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance
OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance
OM-specific MP yield performance
OM-specific MP yield performance
OM-specific MP yield performance
OM-specific MP yield performance
OM-specific MP yield performance
OM-specific MP yield performance
MP performance across OMs
MP performance across OMs
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
##
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202 11 192 77 147 169 78
MP performance across OMs
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
##
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202 11 192
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
##
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202 11 192
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
##
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202 11 192
MP performance across OMs
Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories
Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for model MPs
Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs
Median SSB / dynSSB0 trajectories for empirical MPs
OM-specific MP biomass performance
OM-specific MP biomass performance
OM-specific MP biomass performance
OM-specific MP biomass performance
OM-specific MP biomass performance
OM-specific MP biomass performance
OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance
OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance
OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance
OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance
OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance
OM-specific MP fishing mortality performance
OM-specific MP yield performance
OM-specific MP yield performance
OM-specific MP yield performance
OM-specific MP yield performance
OM-specific MP yield performance
OM-specific MP yield performance
MP performance across OMs
MP performance across OMs
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
##
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202 11 192 77 147 169 78
MP performance across OMs
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
##
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202 11 192
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
##
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202 11 192
## $seed
## [1] 8675309
##
## $iters
## [1] 212 107 202 11 192
MP performance across OMs